Oranga Tamariki - Perceptions of blame.

I parted ways with my social work Master’s degree with the last re-write of legislation. 

Whanau placement children have demonstrably worse outcomes than general placement children because there is a problem with inter-generational disfunction (what is normal for the spider is chaos for the fly). So, if it all REALLY is about what is best for the children, and not a massive power trip the likes of Turia and Raukawa-Tait are embarking on, then it should be as Henerae O'Keef says, that "it doesn't matter if foster parents are black, brown, white, purple or green, they need to have the love for children and a passion in their future".

No one alive today has been colonised or has colonised anyone. Every single person has a choice. Both Maori and Pakeha choose to become addicts, or abuse/neglect their kids. (Remember Maori campaigned to be allowed access to booze in 1947 - now there's some campaigning to prevent Maori access to booze, South Auckland Maori Warden David Ratu and a women in Hawk's Bay). But it's still, and the drugs, apparently Pakeha's fault.

I am told constantly that “Māori were never asked for Pākeha intervention, it was decided by Pākeha that they would intervene anyway."  As if it’s ok with them standards for Maori children should be lower than other children.  No. All children deserve love, care and a decent standard of living (with no abuse) and if families aren’t providing that there needs to be intervention. 

Maori have been part of government decisions for a very long time.  To pretend decisions made by formerly CYFs, and now OT is disingenuous. For example "Instruction in the mission schools was strictly confined to the scriptures, and reading and writing in the Māori language only", and there was high literacy among Maori.  It was a Maori decision that education in 'Native Schools' be in English with a petition to parliament of 337 Maori elders asked 'that there should not be a word of Maori allowed to be spoken in the school. 

I am also told child abuse didn’t exist before Pakeha and that Maori children were stolen to be slaves, and this is where abuse was learnt.  Such a one-eyed view.  Shall we discuss the Chatham Island Moriori and inter-tribal slavery and brutality? No, because that is in the past and as far as I am concerned has no bearing on how anyone chooses to raise their family. 

If these claims are the reason why Maori are so high in OT's stats, how come most Maori can and do look after their kids beautifully.


Ref: 

https://trc.org.nz/sites/trc.org.nz/files/Maori%20language%20and%20the%20Pakeha%20education%20system.pdf


http://www.ahw.org.nz/Portals/5/Resources/Documents-other/2017/Maori%20%26%20Alcohol%20%20history.pdf 


https://mro.massey.ac.nz/bitstream/handle/10179/1612/02_whole.pdf




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

New Zealand turning into Venezuela? More like Rwanda.

Image
  Sounds crazy? Remember this was a society where Hutus and Tutsis lived together, intermarried, lived and worked alongside each other. "In April 1994, when Rwanda erupted into violence, neighbor turned on neighbor, family turned on family, and love turned to hate. The Rwandan genocide turned friends into enemies. The once beautiful country was as ruined as any spot on earth — 800,000 people were brutally slaughtered in 100 days. Rwanda went down the identity politics road, with its citizens ethnicity identified . "Rwanda’s colonial period, during which the ruling Belgians favored the minority Tutsis over the Hutus, exacerbated the tendency of the few to oppress the many, creating a legacy of tension that exploded into violence even before Rwanda gained its independence. Radio hosts discussed discrimination the Hutus suffered under the power of the Tutsis. Strong connotations describing Hutus as slaves during colonization painted the Rwandan genocide as a type of slave rebell
Read more

Update

Image
Yesterday (Thursday) I received a letter from Jeffery Montgomery the Registrar General at Internal Affairs. Some interesting wording: Expressed apologies that the celebrant XXXXXX ruined our wedding. That our complaint would be added to her file and considered at re-registration time. And:   Advising me to lodge a claim with Dispute's Tribunal.  I'd lodged my dispute the day before, all 45 pages (including ceremonies). That letter will be front and centre of my Disputes's hearing paperwork.  XXXXXX still hasn't apologised to us.
Read more

I didn't ask for an extention

Double-speak in academia is certainly a thing and my latest experience is not my first.  Some institutions are worse than others and I returned to the one in this story and it hadn't changed in 10 years.   Hi Lecturer, Thinking ahead to assignment two, the Submission, and the discussion we had around it during the contact course. You mentioned that you will be speaking more about this and the issues the coming election will have on the processes of the House with submission dates etc. My concern is with the time frames, as I need to fit my study around my current obligations, and ideally I would start my research and preparation as soon as I have finished assignment one.  Looking at the current Bills on the NZ Parliament site, there are few accepting submissions and they are closing soon and well before due date, (because the expectation was we were to submit after the academic assignment was marked). A topic of interest to me and social policy is https://www.parliament.nz/en/pb/bi
Read more